Rogers or Eppley for Clavicle Reduction?

I have already consulted with Rogers and am in the process of getting it authorized by insurance. So if I keep going down that road I will probably get the procedure done sooner.

However, I have seen bad rumors floating around about both of them, but also good things. And I just don't know what to do, it's scary.

Edit: Has anyone who has gotten this surgery been able to do athletic upper body stuff like rock climbing or weightlifting?