Buying vs renting an apartment, make it make sense

Let's say you find an area in which there are apartments available for both sale or rent. You can buy the place for $650 000 or rent it for $600 per week.

Now let's look at this over 5 years.

Renting at $600 per week

  • Annual Cost: $31,200
  • 5-Year Cost: $156,000

Buying at $650,000 (Principal & Interest Loan at 6.4%)

  • Annual Interest Paid: $41,600
  • Other Costs (Rates, Insurance, Maintenance): ~$9,700 per year
  • Total Annual Cost: $51,300
  • 5-Year Cost: $256,500
  • Capital Repaid in 5 Years: $35,947 (amount paid towards owning the property)

That saying, rent money is dead money... You are paying more in interest every year for a very long time. $10 000 more. You are only paying off $7000 in capital every year.

On top of that, there's an extra $10 000 per year of additional expenses such as strata, insurance and maintenance. There's people paying $6000 per year on strata alone .

If you were diligent enough to invest that saved $20 000 into ETFs, wouldn't you get further ahead? And those assets would be much more liquid compared to a whole apartment.

Let me put it this way. If I ended up investing in ETFs and put in everything I saved from not buying for 5 years, I'd have at least $100 000 in ETFs. Whereas if I bought the place, I'd only have $35 000 paid off and an enormous mortgage over my head.

Apartments don't appreciate at any decent rate especially nowadays so... why buy?